2017 First Pass Oscar Predictions

Posted by

Hey, that’s a pretty great deal! I’ll be happy to be wrong! I usually end up getting five out of six correct! Should Win: Davis
Will Win: Davis
Mahershala Ali, Moonlight
Jeff Bridges, Hell or High Water
Lucas Hedges, Manchester by the Sea
Dev Patel, Lion
Michael Shannon, Nocturnal Animals
I have a pretty strong feeling this is the category I totally whiff this year, because, honestly, look at this thing. So I think it’s possible any of the remaining four have a chance. Also, Ali’s was 2016’s Hardest Working Man in Show   Business, between Moonlight and Hidden Figures and Luke Cage, so maybe that will pay off. Give it to Mortensen! I suspect it’s going to come down to Huppert and Stone and a lot will depend honestly on how La La Land is doing otherwise. I mean, I get it. Should Win: Ali
Will Win: Ali
Other stuff: I’m rooting for Arrival to win Best Adapted Screenplay (congrats, Eric Heisserer!) but it’s a really tough field this year, not in the least because Moonlight’s script is in there and that may be Berry Jenkins’ compensatory Oscar (see above). As always, these represents my “first blush” guesses — I’ll likely check in closer to the show date to see if anything’s changed. Stop it. You can decide for yourself whether this is a heartwarming story of redemption or just cynicism on the part of the Academy. Henson aren’t (for Arrival and Hidden Figures, respectively) is positively embarrassing. Which means I suspect Chazelle will walk with this one. After that: Well, you got me. Doesn’t this seem like a bit of a cheat to anyone else? I love Streep too. I don’t know Mel Gibson and can’t speak to whether in his heart he’s stopped being an awful, damaged person (He’s stopped drinking, as I understand it, which I think is entirely laudable), but he’s lived up to his end of the bargain, and so here he is, back again. Likewise Mortensen, who is the sort of actor I think Academy members find easier to admire (and occasionally nominate) than to actually give an Oscar to. They’ll be fine. As for the remaining three, Chazelle, Jenkins and Lonergan, here’s a tell as to who might win Director: If any of them wins an Oscar in the Screenwriting categories — Jenkins is up for Adapted, and Chazelle and Lonergan are up in Original — they’re more likely not to win Director. But again, that’s not what I think this nomination is for. Should Win: Huppert
Will Win: Stone
Casey Affleck, Manchester by the Sea
Andrew Garfield, Hacksaw Ridge
Ryan Gosling, La La Land
Viggo Mortensen, Captain Fantastic
Denzel Washington, Fences
Denzel Washington is in my opinion America’s greatest living actor and if you disagree, well, I mean, you’re wrong, aren’t you? Should Win: Jenkins
Will Win: Chazelle
Isabelle Huppert, Elle
Ruth Negga, Loving
Natalie Portman, Jackie
Emma Stone, La La Land
Meryl Streep, Florence Foster Jenkins
Dear Academy: You don’t have to nominate Meryl Streep for every goddamned thing. It doesn’t mean he’ll win. Likewise, Hacksaw Ridge seems unlikely to me; its selection reads more like the Academy welcoming director Mel Gibson back in from the cold than anything else (more on that later). Good for him. And I would never count him out of anything, because again, America’s greatest living actor. It’s got 14 nominations, so if it starts clearing the decks early, Stone has a very good chance; otherwise Huppert, who won a Golden Globe against some of the rest of the field, might find herself with a nice career capstone. Note also that these predictions are as much about what’s won before (and why) and Hollywood politics as it is about the objective quality of the work under consideration, because, hey, when Al Pacino won a Best Actor Oscar for Scent of a Woman (or heck, when Leonardo diCaprio won for The Revenant), it wasn’t because they actually had the best male film performances of the year. First off, Dev Patel is kind of the star of Lion, isn’t he? Octavia Spencer also has an Oscar (in this category) and fairly recently too, so despite her very fine work in Hidden Figures, I suspect this will not be her year. But on the other hand La La Land is about Los Angeles and the industry and has pretty people dancing around and it’s 2017 and the world is shit and maybe we just want a goddamn musical and to smile okay? But at the end of the day I suspect it will be Affleck, who is allegedly awful and also gave a very fine dramatic performance. — which doesn’t help its overall argument). Screenplay Oscars are often “consolation” Oscars for directors — see Orson Welles, Quentin Tarantino and Jane Campion about this — so a win in this category in my opinion boosts the chances of the other guys. Still, two SF/F screenplays in the same year — not bad, says this science fiction author. Right? Stop it. Your thoughts on this year’s nominations (and my predictions)? Should Win: Washington
Will Win: Affleck
Viola Davis, Fences
Naomie Harris, Moonlight
Nicole Kidman, Lion
Octavia Spencer, Hidden Figures
Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea
For my money the best acting category in the awards this year, as long as you don’t count Nicole Kidman, whose presence here is an enduring testament to the power of Harvey Weinstein to get his films jammed into award consideration. I mean, surprise me, Oscar voters! (I’m probably not wrong.) As for Garfield — he’s moved away from Spider-Man at a nice clip, hasn’t he? The only one I’m comfortable suggesting is not in contention is Hedges, but then again, if he does win, you can expect a reasonably good night for Manchester. So I’ve got that going to for me, which is nice. On the animated movie front, I’ll be interested to see whether Moana or Zootopia gets it; I suspect Moana (if Kubo and the Two Strings gets it, I will be shocked but delighted). Okay, then. This year none of the Picture nominees without a directing nod has someone egregiously missing from that slate, so, I think it’s fair to say that Fences, Hell or High Water, Hidden Figures and Lion are just along for the ride this year. Honestly, the fact she’s here for Florence while Amy Adams   or   Taraji P. Maybe the Academy wants to feel what it’s like to be woke. But just give her a damn Lifetime Achievement award already. I mean, Kidman’s fine! I’ll gladly be wrong! Of the remaining five: I loved Arrival but the Academy has a bias against science fiction films; it’s only recently started nominating them for Best Picture on a semi-regular basis, so expecting it to pick one is optimistic, especially when there are other things on the slate that better conform to its overall preferences (also, Amy Adams didn’t get an Actress nod — what the hell? It’s that time of year again where I dust off my “film writer” hat and make guesses on what and who are going to win Oscars in the six major categories (Picture, Director, Actor and Actress, Supporting Actress and Supporting Actor). Likewise, Portman has won recently enough that there’s no great need to give her another one now. So I suspect it’s probably gonna be La La Land, what with its 13 other nominations and all. There are exceptions — see Argo — but they’re just that: Exceptions. (Also, if you want to see the full list of nominees, here you go.)
Hacksaw Ridge
Hell or High Water
Hidden Figures
La La Land
Manchester By the Sea
The Academy allows for up to ten films to be nominated for best picture and this year we have nine, but usually if the film’s director isn’t nominated, a film doesn’t have much of a shot. Stop it. And between Williams and Davis, I think it’s pretty much a coin flip, although I favor Viola Davis, because she won the Golden Globe and because damn it, it’s time. Should Win: Arrival THERE I SAID IT (Note: I am biased as I know the guy whose story it’s based on)
Will Win: La La Land
Damien Chazelle, La La Land
Mel Gibson, Hacksaw Ridge
Barry Jenkins, Moonlight
Kenneth Lonergan, Manchester by the Sea
Denis Villeneuve, Arrival
So,   essentially, here’s the deal Mel Gibson got from Hollywood: Don’t be a public drunken racist and anti-Semite for ten years or so, and we’ll let you back into the club. Let’s get to it. Finally, I suspect Ava   DuVernay is going to get her Oscar in the Documentary category for 13th. The Academy has traditionally liked to pair Best Director and Best Picture but in recent years especially has been more prone to split those votes — three times in the last four years, in fact. Likewise, although this year is a bad year to against La La Land in Original Song, I think the temptation to give Lin-Manuel Miranda his EGOT (actually a PEGOT, because he’s got a Pulitzer, too) will be really strong and anyway it’s not like La La Land won’t win Original Score. This is not to say they’re not worthy, just not likely to win (that said, Lion is probably there mostly as a testament to Harvey Weinstein browbeating Academy voters into a nod). No, they just won a damn Oscar! Likewise I suspect Naomie Harris, a first time Academy nominee, is going to have to get in line behind Davis and Williams, who have been nominated before. Of the four, I judge Villeneuve as the least likely (I think, alas, that Arrival is destined to be a runner-up in a lot of things), but I don’t want to write him off completely. My guess is that Lonergan and Jenkins have very good chances to win in their respective screenwriting categories, and are they going to   complain if they do? I suspect this category will come down to Affleck and Gosling, but in my opinion it’s probably actually   down to Affleck and whether enough Academy voters are squicked about   his allegedly assaulting and harassing behavior to women co-workers on previous films (Spoiler: I don’t think it will matter). So I suspect it will come down to either Moonlight or La La Land. I like both Shannon and Ali and I couldn’t tell you which will win, but maybe Ali, if for no other reason than Moonlight is multiply-nominated and Animals isn’t. Of three remaining, the next off the Oscar train for me would be Manchester by the Sea, which I suspect will be honored in other categories. But among many other things, she’s already got an Oscar, and that in the lead category, so, meh. On one hand Moonlight would be the very woke choice for the Academy, and who knows?  
Share:Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)Click to email (Opens in new window) Aside from Gibson, this is actually a pretty competitive field! (I’m going pause a moment to note that it seems like I’m being unduly harsh to   Lion, which may be possibly unfair to the film, which is perfectly competent tear-jerking Oscar bait. I’m likewise thrilled the deeply weird script for The Lobster got an Oscar nod in Original Screenplay, but it has the same problem as Arrival has: tough field, packed with directors. But I don’t think it’s his year (or Fences‘ year, although come on, getting a whole stack of nominations is no small thing). Leave them in the comments. I think it’s great Ruth Negga has a nomination and I hope she enjoys it, and I hope she’ll be here again some other time; I don’t see much of a chance for her here. I don’t think Jeff Bridges really cares if he wins another Oscar, but he might anyway, just because he’s Jeff Bridges. Sorry, Lion fans!) I think it’s possible Patel gets a nod here, but if he does, I think it’s because of a cynical move on the part of his film company. It also depends on whether (again) La La Land is running the board; if it is, then heck, why not throw this in, too?